What type of reasoning is being challenged in the statement "Because it's wintertime" as an answer to "Why is it so cold outdoors?"

Get more with Examzify Plus

Remove ads, unlock favorites, save progress, and access premium tools across devices.

FavoritesSave progressAd-free
From $9.99Learn more

Prepare for the Academic Games Propaganda Test with flashcards and questions. Review each question with hints and explanations to boost your exam readiness!

The statement "Because it's wintertime" exemplifies begging the question, which occurs when an argument's premises assume the truth of the conclusion instead of providing evidence for it. In this case, the reasoning does not offer an explanation for why it is cold but instead restates a condition (wintertime) that inherently suggests it is cold.

The phrase fails to provide additional context or reasoning about the effects of winter or the mechanisms that lead to cold weather. Instead, it simply highlights the season, which is already implied by the question about cold temperatures. This circular reasoning does not contribute to an actual understanding of why the cold conditions exist, emphasizing the lack of informative substance in the response.

In contrast, other choices involve different logical flaws. Disproving a minor point does not apply because the statement does not challenge a specific argument. A straw man involves misrepresenting someone's argument to make it easier to attack, which is not relevant here. Ad hominem attacks focus on the individual making an argument, rather than addressing the argument itself. Thus, these options do not align with the reasoning demonstrated in the given statement.

Subscribe

Get the latest from Examzify

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy